Agenda and minutes
Venue: Council Chamber - The Guildhall. View directions
Contact: Dinah Lilley 01427 676595
Media
No. | Item |
---|---|
Apologies for Absence Additional documents: Minutes: Councillor Roger Patterson (Chairman) Councillor David Bond Councillor Alexander Bridgwood Councillor Hugo Marfleet Councillor Richard Oaks Councillor Malcolm Parish Councillor Reg Shore Councillor Tom Regis Councillor Angela White
|
|
Presentation of Petition Additional documents: Minutes: A Petition, signed by over 2,000 people, had been received by the Council, stating: “We the undersigned object to West Lindsey District Council’s proposal to charge for car parking in its 3 Market Rasen car parks. We call upon the Council to withdraw the proposal, investigate further the likely effect on businesses and other ways to create more car park spaces. We ask that the Council fully consults with local residents and businesses on any future proposals.”
Mr Adrian Campbell, the Lead Petitioner had been unable to be present at the meeting, therefore the Chairman used her Chair’s discretion to allow persons in the public gallery to speak on the petition.
Two members of the public addressed the Councillors stating that they felt that the introduction of parking charges would finish traders’ businesses. Charges were being removed in other areas as this was felt more attractive to passing trade. If tourists saw parking restrictions they did not stop. Turnover for local traders had dropped over the last four years due to the recession and further losses could not be sustained. Up to 25 shops had been lost in the town. Marshall’s Yard in Gainsborough was attractive to shoppers but could not be compared to Market Rasen and it was feared that small shops would shut down.
Councillor Smith as Ward Member for Market Rasen read out a statement submitted by the Lead Petitioner, which he would have made had he been present.
“Thank you for the opportunity to present and introduce the petition about Market Rasen Car Park charges.
Over 2633 people have signed this petition and the population of Market Rasen is only 3,300 so it shows an immense depth of feeling about this issue.
The second and most important point is that it is NOT a petition asking that the whole issue be abandoned, it is asking to look again into the effect on Market Rasen businesses, come up with revised proposals and fully consult before going ahead.
There are 2 reasons why the issue deserves further thought. One is that the Prosperous Communities Committee has not been given the full facts and the second is that the consultation process was flawed.
There are 2 key facts that the PCC were not made aware of. One is that at the same time as WLDC were considering this, the Scrutiny Committee at ELDC were considering abandoning a charging policy brought in 3 years earlier at 13 car parks because of the damage it had done to businesses there.
The second fact is that despite a WLDC policy to "maintain and enhance the town centre to create a viable and attractive range of shops and services" Market Rasen has actually declined dramatically.
Authoritative statistics from Venuescore that WLDC officers use to show how much Gainsborough has been improved show at the same time how far Market Rasen has declined but this was not reported to the PCC.
Regarding the consultation process there were numerous flaws:- When it was first announced ... view the full minutes text for item 24. |
|
Minutes of the Previous Meetings PDF 285 KB To confirm as a correct record the Minutes of the Annual Meeting of Council held on 9 May 2016.
To confirm as a correct record the Minutes of the Extraordinary Meeting of Council held on 25 May 2016. Additional documents: Minutes: RESOLVED that the minutes of the Annual meeting of Council held on 9 May 2016 be confirmed and signed as a correct record.
RESOLVED that the minutes of the Extraordinary meeting of Council held on 25 May 2016 be confirmed and signed as a correct record.
|
|
Members' Declarations of Interest Members may make any declarations of interest at this point and may also make them at any point during the meeting. Additional documents: Minutes: No declarations were made. |
|
Additional documents: Minutes: The Chairman noted that all items were shown as having been completed.
RESOLVED that the Matters Arising be noted.
|
|
Announcements i) Chairman of the Council ii) Leader of the Council iii) Head of Paid Service Additional documents: Minutes: i) Chairman of the Council
In the absence of the Chairman the Vice Chairman informed Members of some events that she had attended in his stead, namely: Caistor in Bloom; a 100th birthday at Cherry Willingham; and a ceremony marking the anniversary of the Battle of the Somme, at which the soldiers’ stories were very moving.
ii) Leader of the Council
The Leader informed Councillors of meetings he had attended regarding the future of John Coupland Hospital, where, whilst changes would be made but whose closure was not planned.
It was announced that the draft Central Lincolnshire Local Plan had now been submitted to the Planning Inspector. A positive response was hoped for.
Thanks were issued to all involved in the display at the recent Lincolnshire Show, which was felt to have been one of the best ever.
A meeting had taken place with Gainsborough traders to discuss improvements to the town centre.
The Leader then invited Councillor McNeill to present a question which had been submitted following the result of the Referendum.
“Does the Leader agree with me that we are rightly proud
to live in a diverse and tolerant society? That racism, xenophobia
and hate crimes have no place in our country? Would he join me in
condemning racism, xenophobia and hate crimes unequivocally? Making
it clear we will not allow hate to become acceptable?
The Leader gave his assurance of agreement and hoped that Councillors Shore and Devine, the other Group Leaders, would join with him to undertake all possible opportunities to promote tolerance.
iii) Head of Paid Service
The Chief Executive noted that a Devolution workshop had been held prior to the Council meeting and reminded those Members who had not been able to attend that a further workshop was to be held on 13 July.
In noting the two minutes’ silence held prior to commencement of the meeting, the Chief Executive spoke of the shared deep respect of all for Irmgard Parrot, past Chairman of the Council who had recently passed away.
The Chief Executive mentioned a Community Action event recently at the Trinity Arts Centre with an exhibition of work by people with mental health problems or disabilities, which was inspirational.
A meeting had been held in partnership with the Director responsible for the Air Show at Scampton at which assurance was sought that the show would remain at Scampton. The air show was commissioned for three years at RAF Scampton and the Chief Executive was working with the RAF Commander and Director regarding plans and the Council will have an active role as a partner.
|
|
Public Participation Additional documents: Minutes: Group Captain P J Rodgers submitted the following question to the meeting:
“At an Extraordinary Meeting of the Council the Leader compared a Greater Lincolnshire with a Greater Manchester and Cornwall. Is the Council aware that Cornwall is a Unitary Authority with a Leader and Cabinet: and a move to Mayor and Cabinet would have little impact. However, Greater Manchester is made up of 10 metropolitan boroughs, which formed a combined authority in 2011, and moving to a regional authority with a Mayor could be conceived as a rational step. The economy of Greater Manchester is bigger than that of Wales. So could Greater Lincolnshire compare on an extra £15m a year?"
The Leader of the Council responded that he was aware of the different governance systems and maintained that the changes made sense. Whilst he had not previously made direct comparisons with Cornwall and Manchester, he noted that Devolution had made a difference of £11 per capita in Manchester, whereas in West Lindsey that difference would be £13.63.
|
|
Questions Pursuant to Council Procedure Rule No.9 Additional documents: Minutes: Councillor Trevor Young submitted the following question to the meeting: “Civil Parking Enforcement
The Leader of the Council responded “When Civil Parking Enforcement was implemented
it encompassed two elements, on street parking (operated by LCC)
and the off street car parks operated by districts. West Lindsey is only responsible for “Off
Street” parking in its own car parks.
Councillor Young, given the opportunity of a supplementary question, quoted several instances of over aggressive enforcement which had upset residents and asked that the matter be re-considered by the relevant Committee.
The Chairman assured Councillor Young that the matter would be taken into consideration during the pending review.
During the debate on Market Rasen parking the Leader of the Council had ... view the full minutes text for item 30. |
|
Motions pursuant to Council Procedure Rule No.10 Additional documents: Minutes: None received
|
|
Appointment to Rural Transport Working Group PDF 145 KB Additional documents: Minutes: At the Prosperous Communities Committee on 29 October 2015 it was resolved that a Member Working Group for Rural Transport be established to assist officers in working up projects and six Members were appointed to the group.
Appointments to the Rural Transport Member Working Group must be legally and constitutionally confirmed at Full Council. At Annual Council on 9 May 2016 Paper D set out appointments of Members to committees, boards and other bodies. The confirmation of appointments to the Rural Transport Member Working Group were not included at this meeting due to on-going work to develop rural transport projects.
Following the above meetings Officers have been working to develop further projects and liaise with other stakeholders including Lincolnshire County Council as the Transport Authority. It is now an appropriate time to hold the first Member Working Group meeting for Rural Transport, therefore membership required confirmation.
RESOLVED that the following Members be appointed to the Rural Transport Working Group. Councillor Lesley Rollings Councillor Di Rodgers Councillor Jessie Milne Councillor Steve England Councillor Paul Howitt-Cowan Councillor Lewis Strange
|
|
Minutes of Committee meetings To receive the minutes of Committee meetings published since the Council meeting on 11 April 2016 Additional documents: Minutes: 33 TO RECEIVE THE MINUTES OF COMMITTEE MEETINGS PUBLISHED SINCE THE COUNCIL MEETING ON 11 APRIL 2016.
RESOLVED that the minutes of Committee meetings published since the Council meeting on 11 April 2016 be received.
Note The Leader took a further opportunity to remind Members of the second Devolution workshop to be held on 13 July and requested that questions be submitted in advance in order for answers to be researched.
|